GRB 240821A
GCN Circular 38077
Subject
GRB 240821A: further radio observations with the VLA
Date
2024-11-05T09:12:17Z (a year ago)
From
Stefano Giarratana at INAF-OAB <s.giarratana@ira.inaf.it>
Via
email
S. Giarratana (INAF-OAB), M. Giroletti (INAF-IRA),
G. Ghirlanda (INAF-OAB), N. Di Lalla (Stanford Univ.),
N. Omodei (Stanford Univ.), O. S. Salafia (INAF-OAB)
At 04:55:36 UT on 2024 Sept 18 (T_mid = 27.5 days post-burst)
and at 05:38:46 UT on 2024 Oct 8 (T_mid = 47.5 days post-burst)
the Karl G. Jansky VLA observed the field of GRB 240821A
(Fermi GBM team, GCN 37219; SVOM team, GCN 37220, 37226)
in three bands, with central frequencies of 6, 10 and 15 GHz.
The standard 3C48 was used as bandpass and flux density
calibrator, while J2358-1020 was used as phase calibrator.
From a preliminary analysis, we do not detect the radio counterpart
of GRB 240821A. We derive the following upper limits (UL; 3sigma):
==================================================
T_mid Freq UL r.m.s. Beam PA
[days] [GHz] [uJy] [uJy/b] [arcsec] [deg]
==================================================
27.5 6 21 7 1.07x0.78 -21
27.5 10 22 7 0.82x0.48 -10
27.5 15 27 9 0.57x0.32 -16
47.5 6 21 7 1.26x0.46 71
47.5 10 27 9 0.91x0.28 66
47.5 15 24 8 0.51x0.20 73
==================================================
We would like to thank the staff of the VLA for approving, executing,
and processing the observations.
The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the National
Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement by Associated
Universities, Inc.
These observations were carried out as part of project SF171028,
approved in the framework of the Fermi - NRAO joint program agreement.
GCN Circular 37931
Subject
GRB 240821A: Keck/LRIS spectroscopic observations
Date
2024-10-28T17:21:08Z (a year ago)
From
Weikang Zheng at UC Berkeley <weikang@berkeley.edu>
Via
legacy email
WeiKang Zheng, Thomas G. Brink, Alexei V. Filippenko (UC Berkeley), and Yi
Yang (Tsinghua Univ., Beijing), report on behalf of the KAIT GRB team:
We observed the location of the GRB 240821A optical afterglow
(Quirola-Vasquez et al., GCN 37319) with the Low Resolution Imaging
Spectrometer (LRIS; Oke et al. 1995) with the Keck I 10 m telescope by
centering on the slit the host-galaxy counterpart from the Legacy Survey as
noticed by Quirola-Vasquez et al. (GCN 37319). Observations were performed
on Sep. 2, 2024, and consisted of 4 x 1200 s exposures with the 600/4000
grism and 400/8500 grating. The spectrum has low signal-to-noise ratio
owing to the faintness of the host galaxy. We detect and confirm the
emission line at 8123 Ang reported by Saccardi et al. (GCN 37369) and
Schneider et al. (GCN 37731) from VLT/X-shooter data. The [N II] 6584 and
possibly [O II] 3727 emission lines reported by Schneider et al. (GCN 37731)
are marginally detected. These results confirm the host-galaxy redshift of
z = 0.238.
The data presented herein were obtained at the W. M. Keck Observatory,
which is operated as a scientific partnership among the California
Institute of Technology, the University of California, and the National
Aeronautics and Space Administration. The Observatory was made possible by
the generous financial support of the W. M. Keck Foundation. The authors
wish to recognize and acknowledge the very significant cultural role and
reverence that the summit of Maunakea has always had within the indigenous
Hawaiian community. We are most fortunate to have the opportunity to
conduct observations from this mountain.
GCN Circular 37731
Subject
GRB 240821A: Host galaxy redshift from VLT/X-shooter
Date
2024-10-07T15:42:50Z (a year ago)
From
Benjamin Schneider at MIT <bschn@mit.edu>
Via
Web form
B. Schneider (MIT), A. Rossi (INAF-OAS), M. Ferro (INAF-OAB), H. Fausey (GWU), A. L. Thakur (INAF-IAPS), A. Martin-Carrillo (UCD), D. B. Malesani (DAWN/NBI and Radboud Univ.), N. R. Tanvir (U. Leicester), A. J. Levan (Radboud Univ. and Warwick Univ.), J. T. Palmerio (CEA), A. Saccardi (GEPI/Obs. de Paris), S. D. Vergani (GEPI/Obs. de Paris) report on behalf of the Stargate collaboration:
We observed the location of the SVOM and Fermi short GRB 240821A (Cangemi et al., GCN 37220; He et al., GCN 37226; Murphy et al., GCN 37232; Dalessi & Meegan, GCN 37239, Quirola-Vasquez et al., GCN 37319) with the X-shooter spectrograph mounted on the ESO VLT UT3 (Melipal) as a follow-up to our previous VLT/X-shooter observation (Saccardi et al., GCN 37369). The observation consisted of two consecutive observations of 4x1200 s each, with mid-times at 03:53:33 UT and 05:18:58 UT on 2024 October 1 (~40.4 days after the trigger). The seeing delivered is significantly better than for our previous observation reported in GCN 37369.
In addition to the emission line at 8120 AA mentioned by Saccardi et al. (GCN 37369), which is clearly detected also in the new spectra, two fainter features are also visible. This allows solving the conundrum from the previous observation, as the three lines nicely match [O II] 3729, H alpha, and [N II] 6584, all at a common redshift z = 0.238.
We acknowledge the expert support from the ESO observing staff at Paranal, in particular Jonathan Smoker and Cedric Ledoux.
GCN Circular 37533
Subject
GRB 240821A: radio observation with the VLA
Date
2024-09-17T15:12:32Z (a year ago)
From
Stefano Giarratana at INAF-OAB <s.giarratana@ira.inaf.it>
Via
email
S. Giarratana (INAF-OAB), M. Giroletti (INAF-IRA),
G. Ghirlanda (INAF-OAB), N. Di Lalla (Stanford Univ.),
N. Omodei (Stanford Univ.), O. S. Salafia (INAF-OAB)
At 04:07:30 UT on 2024 September 6 (T_mid = 15.43 days post-burst)
the Karl G. Jansky VLA observed the field of GRB 240821A
(Fermi GBM team, GCN 37219; SVOM team, GCN 37220, 37226) at a
central frequency of 6, 10 and 15 GHz.
The standard 3C48 was used as bandpass and flux density
calibrator, while J2358-1020 was used as phase calibrator.
From a preliminary analysis, we do not detect the radio counterpart
of GRB 240821A. During the observation, the VLA site was hit by a
thunderstorm, which heavily affected the success of the experiment.
We derive the following upper limits (UL; 3sigma):
==================================================
T_mid Freq UL r.m.s. Beam PA
[days] [GHz] [uJy] [uJy/b] [arcsec] [deg]
==================================================
15.43 6 51 17 1.75x0.93 -38
15.43 10 54 18 0.95x0.62 -29
15.43 15 130 43 0.87x0.38 -44
==================================================
We would like to thank the staff of the VLA for approving, executing,
and processing the observations.
The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a facility of the National
Science Foundation operated under cooperative agreement by Associated
Universities, Inc.
These observations were carried out as part of project SF171028,
approved in the framework of the Fermi - NRAO joint program agreement.
GCN Circular 37369
Subject
GRB 240821A: VLT spectroscopic observations
Date
2024-09-01T17:31:31Z (a year ago)
From
Daniele B. Malesani at IMAPP / Radboud University <d.malesani@astro.ru.nl>
Via
Web form
A. Saccardi (GEPI/Obs. de Paris), M. Ferro (INAF-OAB), A. J. Levan (Radboud Univ. & Warwick Univ.), A. Rossi (INAF-OAS), S. D. Vergani (GEPI/Obs. de Paris), D. B. Malesani (DAWN/NBI and Radboud Univ.), B. P. Gompertz (U. Birmingham), A. Martin-Carrillo (UCD), K. Wiersema (Hertfordshire Univ.), D. Xu (NAOC), report on behalf of the Stargate collaboration:
Following the identification of the optical afterglow (Quirola-Vasquez et al., GCN 37319) of GRB 240821A (Cangemi et al., GCN 37220; He et al., GCN 37226; Murphy et al., GCN 37232; Dalessi & Meegan, GCN 37239), we obtained 4x1200 s of observations with the X-shooter instrument at the ESO VLT UT3 (mid time 2024 Aug 30.3578 UT, that is, 8.8 days after the trigger). These observations reveal a continuum across the spectral range 4000-20000 AA, and a single clear emission line at 8120 AA. While the presence of a substantial continuum blueward of 8120 AA rules out that this line is Ly-alpha, it is difficult to conclusively determine a redshift value based on only a single line. We consider three possibilities below.
A) The emission line could arise from the [O II] doublet (3726, 3729) at z = 1.18. In this scenario the other strong emission lines lie in the IR regime, where sensitivity is poorer and sky background higher. The observed spectral energy distribution of the host galaxy from the Legacy and VISTA surveys would also provide the best match at this redshift. However, the resolution of X-shooter should clearly resolve the two components of the doublet, and, while a very weak excess may be present at 8215 AA (the expected location of the bluer component of the doublet), the observed intensity ratio would be inconsistent with the expectations for either high or low density media.
B) The line could be from [O III] (5007 AA) at z = 0.62. In this scenario, both [O III] 4959 and H-beta would lie in close proximity in the spectrum, although are expected to have lower flux, and hence poorer signal to noise than the observed line. There is no detection of any emission at the expected location of either.
C) The line may come from H-alpha at z = 0.24. Since H-alpha may well be the brightest line within the host galaxy (especially for a short-GRB host), the non-detection of other emission features at the same redshift, but at bluer wavelengths is less problematic because they may be fainter and/or extinguished. This may also be supported by an apparent decrease in the galaxy continuum at ~4500 AA, which could be due to the Balmer break, although the signal to noise is poor in this region.
The detection of a single line does not enable at the current time an unambiguous redshift determination, but does suggest it must be one of the above possibilities. We note that all of these lie outside the formal 1-sigma range of the photometric redshift determination from the Legacy survey (z = 0.488 +/- 0.074; Zhou et al. 2021, MNRAS, 501, 3309). Further analysis is ongoing, and we will update the community should this reveal a stronger conclusion regarding the burst redshift.
We acknowledge expert help of the ESO observing staff at Paranal, in particular Thomas Rivinius and Matias Jones.
GCN Circular 37323
Subject
GRB 240821A: PRIME near-infrared observations
Date
2024-08-28T16:59:13Z (a year ago)
From
Joe Durbak at UMD <gcn.joedurbak@gmail.com>
Via
Web form
J. Durbak (UMD), E. Troja (U Rome), S. Atri(U Rome), A. S. Kutyrev (NASA/GSFC), O. Guiffreda (UMD), K. De (MIT), S. B. Cenko (NASA/GSFC)
Following the SVOM localization (GCN 37220), we observed the field of GRB 240821A in H-band with PRIME ~30 hours after the trigger. The total exposure time was 1800s.
At the position of the candidate optical counterpart (GCN 37319), we detect a source with H~20 mag, calibrated versus nearby 2MASS stars and not corrected for Galactic extinction.
Further observations to assess variability are planned.
PRIME is a 1.8m telescope with 1.56 square degree FOV (0.5 arcsec/pixel) located in Sutherland, South Africa at the South African Astronomical Observatory (SAAO) (Kutyrev et al. 2023, Yama et al. 2023).
We thank the Osaka University observers at PRIME and the staff at SAAO for their support with these observations.
GCN Circular 37319
Subject
SVOM GRB 240821A: optical afterglow discovery
Date
2024-08-28T15:57:55Z (a year ago)
From
Daniele B. Malesani at IMAPP / Radboud University <d.malesani@astro.ru.nl>
Via
Web form
J. Quirola-Vasquez (Radboud Univ.), D. B. Malesani (DAWN/NBI and Radboud Univ.), A. J. Levan (Radboud Univ. & Warwick Univ.), P. G. Jonker (Radboud Univ), F. E. Bauer (PUC), J. van Dalen (Radboud Univ.), M. E. Ravasio (Radboud Univ.), D. Mata Sanchez (IAC), M. A. P. Torres (IAC), A. Martin-Carrillo (UCD), S. D. Vergani (GEPI / Obs. de Paris) report on behalf of a larger collaboration:
We observed the location of the candidate X-ray afterglow Turpin et al., GCN 37230; Bernardini et al., GCN 37249; Turpin et al., GCN 37316